Везде
Legal Force of an Administrative Act: The Problem of Definition
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
Legal Force of an Administrative Act: The Problem of Definition
Annotation
PII
S1605-65900000622-5-1
DOI
10.61205/S160565900029927-3
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Oleg Sherstoboev 
ORCID: 0000-0001-6972-8241
Occupation: Cand. Sci. (Law), Assoc. Prof., Dean, Law Faculty, NSUEM
Affiliation: Novosibirsk State University of Economics and Management, Novosibirsk, Russia
Edition
Volume 28 Issue 8
Pages
146-159
Abstract

The legal force of an administrative act determines its validity, affects the powers of an administrative body that adopted this act to change or cancel it, and the legal force makes the act binding on every administrative authority and every person interested in this act. This term has not yet been fully studied and is absent from Russian legislation. There are some questions about the implementation of the theory of the substantive and formal legal force of an administrative act into the doctrine. There are also problems of the relationship between the legal force of the original act and the act derived from it. It is necessary to clarify the possibility of using administrative discretion when resolving issues of the legal force of administrative acts. To research legal force of an administrative act, traditional methods of legal study were used, especially the historical-law method and the comparative law method, which are of great importance for this article. They have allowed to find Russian tradition, which has to be used to develop the doctrine of legal force of an administrative act, and the main foreign legal research on this subject could be compared with Russian thought and common features were discovered that could also be used to improve the Russian doctrine. As a result, the terms substantive and formal legal force should be returned to the Russian legal vocabulary, since they were used to describe legal force in our legal tradition. Interesting results can be obtained by comparing judgements and administrative acts, and the specificity of administrative acts will be emphasized. This way allows to apply some legal constructions characteristic of a judicial theory well developed in practice, including the “Roman basis” of the legal force of an administrative act. The division of administrative acts into void and voidable will make it possible to clarify ideas about their legal force, as well as the powers of authorities to amend or cancel such acts. The scope of administrative discretion when deciding questions of the validity of void and voidable acts will also vary.

Keywords
legal force, administrative act (decision), valid administrative act, invalid administrative act, administrative procedures, administrative discretion
Date of publication
22.08.2024
Number of purchasers
0
Views
18
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should pay the subscribtion

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article and additional services
Subscription benefits
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue and additional services
Subscription benefits
0 RUB / 0.0 SU
All issues and additional services for 2024
Subscription benefits
800 RUB / 80.0 SU

References



Additional sources and materials

1. Starilov Yu. N. (ed.). General administrative law. 2nd ed. Voronezh, 2016. (In Russ.) 
2. Dyuryagin I.Ya. Law and management. Moscow, 1981. (In Russ.) 
3. Kozlov Yu.M. Administrative law. Moscow, 1999. (In Russ.) 
4. Davydov K. V. Administrativnye protsedury: rossiyskiy i zarubezhnyy opyt. Novosibirsk, 2020. 
5. Kofanov L. L. (ed.). Digests of Justinian. 2nd ed. Vol. 1. Kn. I—IV. Moscow, 2008. (In Russ.) 
6. Engel Ch. Wiedergelesen: Otto Mayer: Deutsches Verwaltungsrecht, 3. Aufl., 1924. Juristen Zeitung, 2006. Heft 23. 
7. Mayer O. Deutches Verwaltungsrecht. Bd. I. Leipzig, 1895. 
8. Evtikhiev A. F. Zakonnaya sila aktov administratsii. Lyublin, 1911. 
9. Pakhomov I. N. Acts of the Soviet state Administration. Sovetskoe administrativnoe pravo (Obshchaya i Osobennaya chasti). Moscow, 1973. (In Russ.) 
10. Isakova K. S. O ponyatii otmeny i priostanovleniya aktov upravleniya. Tezisy dokladov na teoreticheskoy konferentsii aspirantov Instituta gosudarstva i prava AN SSSR i Yuridicheskogo fakul'teta MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova. Moscow, 1986. 
11. Vasil'eva Ya.V . Legal nature of the legal act of management. Natsional'naya assotsiatsiya uchenykh, 2020, no. 54-2, pp. 40—42. (In Russ.) 12. Nozdrachev A. F. Administrativnye akty: ponyatie, priznaki, dinamika. In: Khabrieva T. Y., Marku Zh. (eds). Administrative procedures and control in the light of european experience. Moscow, 2011. (In Russ.) 
13. Slesareva E. S. Individual'nye akty upravleniya. Cand. diss. Moscow, 1984. 
14. Vasil'eva A. F. Obyazatel'nost' administrativnogo akta kak proyavlenie ego material'noy zakonnoy sily. In: Khvan L. B. (ed.). Nemetskaya doktrina administrativnogo prava i stanovlenie instituta administrativnykh protsedur v stranakh Tsentral'noy Azii: mater. mezhdunar. konf., priurochennoy k 45-letiyu so dnya prinyatiya Zakona ob administrativnykh protsedurakh Germanii, Tashkent, 25 May 2021: uchenye zapiski Instituta gosudarstva i prava Akademii nauk Respubliki Uzbekistan, 2021. Vol. 1. Tashkent, 2022. 
15. Novoselov V. I. Zakonnost' aktov organov upravleniya. Moscow, 1968. 
16. Elistratov A. I. Osnovnye nachala administrativnogo prava. Moscow, 1917. 
17. Windoffer A. Die Bestandskraft von Verwaltungsakten und ihre Überwindung durch Betroffene. Juristische Ausbildung, 2017, vol. 39, iss. 11. 
18. Savigny F. K. Sistema sovremennogo rimskogo prava. Vol. IV. Translated from German. Ed. by O. Kutateladze, V. Zubar'. Moscow, 2016. 
19. Vedel' Zh. Administrativnoe pravo Frantsii. Moscow, 1973. 
20. Künnecke M. Tradition and Change in Administrative Law. An Anglo-German Comparison. Berlin; Heidelberg, 2007. 
21. Studenikin S. S. Sotsialisticheskaya sistema gosudarstvennogo upravleniya. V nauchnaya konferentsiya, posvyashchennaya tridtsatiletiyu sovetskogo gosudarstva i prava: Tezisy dokladov. 4—10 December 1947. Voenno-yuridicheskaya akademiya Vooruzhennykh sil SSSR. Moscow, 1947. 
22. Kozlov Yu. M. Organy sovetskogo gosudarstvennogo upravleniya (ponyatie i konstitutsionnaya sistema). Moscow, 1960. 
23. Lazarev B. M. Kompetentsiya organa gosudarstva: prava i obyazannosti ili pravosposobnost'? Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo, 1968, no. 11. 
24. Kvosta P. Znachenie i predely zakonnoy sily administrativnykh aktov v Avstrii, ili “udivitel'nye posledstviya zakonnoy sily”. Ezhegodnik publichnogo prava 2018: Printsipy administrativnykh protsedur i administrativnogo sudoproizvodstva. Moscow, 2018. 
25. Chenerelli A. Administrative Procedures in Italian Law. Courier of Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL), 2019, no. 6, pp. 165—172. (In Russ.) 
26. Tarzia A. Public administration. In: Ferrari G. F. (ed.). Introduction to Italian Public Law. Giuffrè Editore, 2008. 
27. Sundberg R. A. Functus Officio and the Prerogative Writ of Prohibition. Melbourne University Law Review, 1970, vol. 7, iss. 4. 
28. Kofanov L. L. (ed.). Digesta Ivstiniani. Transl. from Latin, vol. 6. Moscow, 2005. 
29. Henrico R. The Functus Officio Doctrine and Invalid Administrative Action in South African Administrative Law: A Flexible Approach. Speculum Juris, 2020, vol. 34, no. 2. 
30. Wong A. S. P. Doctrine of Functus Officio: The Changing Face of Finality's Old Guard. The Canadian Bar Review, 2020, vol. 98, no. 3. 
31. Broker L. Otmena administrativnykh aktov v sootvetstvii s nemetskim zakonodatel'stvom. Ezhegodnik publichnogo prava 2016: Administrativnyy akt. Moscow, 2016. 
32. Mitskevich L. A. Ocherki teorii administrativnogo prava: sovremennoe napolnenie. Moscow, 2015. 
33. Adams T. The Standard Theory of Administrative Unlawfulness. The Cambridge Law Journal, 2017, vol. 76, iss. 2. 
34. Forsyth C. The Legal Effect of Unlawful Administrative Acts: The Theory of the Second Actor Explained and Developed. Amicus Curiae, 2001, iss. 35

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate